lucianne goldberg son dies

I have been a loyal reader of lucianne.com for many years. Its home. [6], Goldberg started her literary career at a very early age at The Washington Post, during her secondary education. First Tony Snow, now JonahOH LORD :(! Lucianne Goldberg, the conservative literary agent who played a pivotal role in exposing the affair between Monica Lewinsky and Bill Clinton, died Wednesday at 87. Tough to top that as a legacy. It's always fun to read. Purr, Baby, Purr (1971), written with Jeannie Sakol, was an anti-feminist manifesto that suggested that women think of their bodies as a switchboard with all sorts of lovely buttons and plug-ins.. It is printed out and in my moms memory box. But it was the Clinton scandal that guaranteed Ms. Goldberg her place in political history. I waited almost a year to get my membership. Posted on 02/12/2011 8:12:03 AM PST by Samizdat. Goldbergs son, political commentator and author Jonah Goldberg, posted Thursday on Twitter that his mother died Wednesday at her home. Lucianne.com has been my first stop nearly every morning since, if not exactly the beginning, very soon after. So I did. Legal Statement. Now I am quickly approaching the same age as Mom was when she passed, but have not gone a day without coming here first. She will be missed by many, many people. R.I.P. May God bless this fine lady, she helped to bring His Light to those of us being deceived. Prayers and condolences to her family and friends. I've done much reflection about Lucianne today and about the conversations we shared over the years. There are several Conservative talk shows I listen too that obviously get their material from Lucianne. The one silver lining in her leaving us is that she is no longer living in the disaster of the city of New York. Condolences to the family. Goldberg explained that she had given Tripp incorrect advice, telling her it was legal to make secret recordings. She will be greatly missed. Old Joe Biden piled on with that one four days ago from Portland, literally between gobbles of ice cream, horning in on another country's internal affairs. [20][21] Goldberg also brought the tapes to the attention of lawyers working on the Paula Jones sexual harassment case against Clinton. So sad. Many of you have freely expressed your lack of care for her son in strong words here, but you were able to do so. I found Lucianne from a link on Drudge. America has lost a great patriot and we all lost good friend. She and Mr. Cummings divorced in 1963. It has been such a comfort so oftenknowing you're not alone. Paranoia and fearmongering -- you can just smell it among the Democrats and their boosters. Do you have information you want to share with HuffPost? Early on, you established ground rules that allowed posters to disagree, but required them to do so respectfully and without personal attacks on each other. We'll miss you terribly. Lucianne.com is at the top of my bookmark list and has been for years. My sympathy to your family and the LDotters. You've successfully subscribed to this newsletter! This is my favorite place on the internet. She always answered my emails and I'l always love her for that because she remembered who had been around since the first days. I too remember when SHE would answer an email. Truly a great lady. Needless to say email to the family would overwhelm at this time. There is a thread here to express condolences. They claimed Republicans were going to steal grandma's Social Security check and tax veterans benefits, among other unpopular ideas no credible party would ever endorse. But she has left a whole in our lives that we can never fill completely. Rest in peace dear Lucianne. Pelosi herself, meanwhile, is fundraising on the back of the attack. Remember the Thanksgiving Recipe threads? May she rest in eternal peace. stats revealed that his show hasdriven down the time slot for CNN over 20 percent in comparison to how Sunday nights were ranking before his start. Many thanks to the folks who post articles here from a variety of sources and condolences and prayers to the Goldberg family. This site has been my home - my refuge - for twenty five years. [36], Goldberg was married to Sidney Goldberg, a newspaper executive with United Features Syndicate from 1966 until his death in 2005. Lucianne is the 1st tab on any browser I open. '"[24] Author Jeffrey Toobin named her as one of the seven "Key Players" in the impeachment. NEW YORK (AP) Lucianne Goldberg, a literary agent and key figure in the 1998 impeachment of President Bill Clinton over his affair with Monica Lewinsky, has died at the age of 87. Upon hearing of the auction, the First Lady became irate, and demanded that the note be returned to the White House. who loved her.. Thanks to Lucianne for providing this most informative and engaging website all of these many past years. Lucy leaves behind great memories & a super great site that I hope lives on forever. The journalist Jonah Goldberg, her son, confirmed the death. Clarice Feldman, by Like Mr. Lifson, I have visited Lucianne.com every morning (and frequently throughout the day) for over 20 years. I could not stay another day, To laugh, to love, to work, to play. I have been with her DAILY for 20+ years, she has owned a big part of my life. RIP Lucianne! Many times I am online reading and as they're talking, and I can follow along with each story. Its a salon not a saloon, but Lucians was a forgiving person and let me back after making amends. Lucianne Goldberg, a literary agent and key figure in the 1998 impeachment of President Bill Clinton over his affair with Monica Lewinsky, has died at the age of 87. You have done well. Goldberg later said she was glad Clinton had been caught at something.. To Jonah, I am so terribly sorry. With a deep, deep sadness my condolences to the family! Lucianne Goldberg, best known for her role in uncovering Clinton-Lewinsky affair, dies at 87 Lucianne Goldberg was a longtime conservative activist and literary agent By Bradford Betz |. [6] She received national media attention in 1965 when she attempted to sell a handwritten note from Jackie Kennedy to Lady Bird Johnson through an auction house for $1000 ($8599 in today's dollars). Condolences and prayers to all of her family. As Radar Online reports, the results are dismal: Heres how. Goldberg's son, political commentator and author Jonah Goldberg, posted Thursday on Twitter that his mother died Wednesday at her home. CNN Sans & 2016 Cable News Network. Farewell Miss Lucianne, and thank you team for keeping her dream alive. It is shocking, but not surprising, that violence is the result. Although Lucianne Goldberg has receded somewhat from the public eye over the years, her son, Jonah Goldberg, has taken a front-and-center role when it comes to conservative commentary in the. That book never happened, but by 1995 the year Ms. Lewinsky began her White House internship Ms. Tripp was developing her own book proposal. Lucianne Goldberg, a longtime conservative activist whose agency specialized in right-wing books, gained national prominence for advising her friend Linda Tripp to secretly tape Tripp's conversations with Lewinsky, a former White House intern who had been involved in a sexual relationship with Clinton. Lucianne Goldberg (ne Steinberger; April 29, 1935 - October 26, 2022), also known as Lucianne Cummings, was an American literary agent and author. The zip ties, in particular, echoed what multiple suspects in the Jan. 6 insurrection at the U.S. Capitol Building in Washington were carrying, Former President Barack Obama took his road show to the motor city where he sought to whip up enthusiasm among black voters, a demographic that it is imperative to get to the polls if his party is to have any chance of holding on to one-party rule, and things nearly got ugly when a crowd clamored for violence against a heckler. God bless you, your family, and the staffers you have entrusted to preserve your legacy. She was also a patriot who expressed her love of this country with both political fierceness and penetrating wit. May Joshua rest in peace. Lucianne's community and Rush were north stars. I wasn't expecting this at all and am at a loss for words, with an overwhelming sense of gratitude for Lucianne. Had my hand slapped a few times by our gracious hostess. A bit hardened around the edges. She also ghostwrote for celebrities;[5] the romance novel Washington Wives (1987) (penned under the name of Maureen Dean, wife of Watergate figure John Dean) is one of her behind-the-scenes works. Anthony Scott, by He did not give a cause of death. Lucianne would not approve. May God hold you in the palm of his hand. However, she said that DePape appeared to share her left-wing views when they were involved. Let them take their best shot. Monica Showalter, by Rest well dear Lucianne! From the hymn For All the Saints: The New York Times described her as an agent with a taste for right-wing, tell-all attack books in an article published amid the fallout from the Lewinsky tapes. The world is going to miss her! [19] Charges against Tripp were later dropped. Not one day went by without me stopping in this oasis with my morning coffee, to stay informed and commune with fellow patriots. I have also been here for 20 years, at least and am grateful for what she has done for conservative news and discussion. Going to Lucianne.com this morning, as I do every morning, I was shocked and saddened to read that its proprietor, Lucianne Goldberg, has passed away: I found a great place to share in ideas plus ways to find good reading content. I love reading everyone's posts. Her son, journalist Jonah. what every one else has said..a thousand times over. The Republican Party and its mouthpieces now regularly spread hate and deranged conspiracy theories. This one hurts. Thank you, Lucianne. RIP Ms. Lucianne. RIP Lucianne. What is it about Democrats and ice cream? Nancy Pelosi disgusted many with her ostentatious fridge full of expensive ice cream at the height of the coronavirus lockdowns. A friendship shared, a laugh, a kiss, Ah, yes, these things too I will miss. President Trump is the most popular politician in the country. So very sorry to hear this. By entering your email and clicking Sign Up, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. Thank you, dear lady for creating a place for like minds to gather. And there is enormous freedom in not caring whether people like you., Lucianne Goldberg, Who Helped Expose Clinton Affair, Dies at 87, https://www.nytimes.com/2022/10/27/us/politics/lucianne-goldberg-dead.html. "The bird is freed," he tweeted, referencing Twitter's bird logo in an apparent nod to his desire to see the company have fewer limits on content that can be posted. God bless Lucianne Goldberg. May the God of all comfort be close to this family, both natural and this community she created. Even though I never had the pleasure to meet her in person, she had a serious impact on my life and keeping me going when life is dealing us lemons. The New York Times described her as an agent with a taste for right-wing, tell-all attack books in an article published amid the fallout from the Lewinsky tapes. The former wife of David DePape, the suspect who allegedly assaulted Paul Pelosi with a hammer last week, revealed that the man has been mentally ill for a long time. There is not a more readable website than right here. We have lost a child and a grand child, one in the womb, one to SIDS..you never forget and the strangest of events trigger a memory. Holy crap. My respect for her only grew through the years. Before the Clinton scandal, Ms. Goldberg was the author or co-author of four books. Since it has been several years since focus was on the murder of Seth Rich and the publication by Julian Assange. May you now rest in eternal peace. Today they got caught putting out bare naked disinformation about Republican plans for the country once they win the midterm election. Editors, by Greg Roumeliotis, by I have been here since the beginning and exchanged e-mails with er over the years. He did not give a cause of death. sweet is the calm of paradise the blest. She led a 2022 post with a cartoon showing an Olympic torch labeled Biden misinformation lies fraud deceit.. A longtime Clinton foe, Goldberg had met Tripp while working on a proposal for a book on the death of Vince Foster, a Clinton aide whose suicide sparked conservative conspiracy theories. In 1972, she was paid by a friend of Richard Nixon to spy on the McGovern campaign and the reporters covering it, posing as a member of the . [10][11], In 1970, Goldberg and her friend Jeannie Sakol founded an organization called the "Pussycat League" to oppose the women's liberation movement,[10] and in 1971 she and Sakol published Purr Baby Purr, a critique of feminism. Thanks, Lucianne. RIP dear lady. When she handled Kitty Kelleys biography Elizabeth Taylor: The Last Star (1981), she neglected to pay the author for the books European sales. I know Rush visited here frequently, I'm positive he posted occasionally too. Her earlier career included the 1970 co-founding of a group called the Pussycat League that campaigned against feminism and the Equal Rights Amendment. She will truly be missed! They cite 'inflation,' forgetting that they were the ones who enacted the big spending that triggered the inflation and Joe embraced, and somehow, Joe hasn't magically stopped it. Lulianne and welcome. Dear Goldberg family: I just lost my Mama earlier this year so I know what you are going through. Such a great community. Ms. Goldberg addressed journalists outside her New York apartment in 1998. Sad news today. I saw this posted on William Jacobson's Legal Insurrection site, and came over to post my condolences. Rest In peace and God Bless her staff and family. Rest In Peaceyou done goodreal good! Ms. Goldberg suggested that Ms. Tripp buy a tape recorder at Radio Shack. She will be truly missed - she was an anchor thru much turmoil. Beard Beard is an American slang term describing a person who is used, knowingly or unknowingly, as a date, romantic partner (boyfriend or girlfriend), or spouse either to conceal infidelity or to conceal ones sexual orientation. Was living and working in Manhattan (27th and 2nd Ave) when I first became aware of Lucianne.com and was overjoyed several years later after we moved to KY when she personally replied to an open invitation to the KY Derby. I am thankful that Lucianne put down some strong Rules here and enforced them. Lucianne Goldberg established the premiere online forum. They included Mark Fuhrman, the Los Angeles detective who wrote about the O.J. Our old friend John Podhoretz offers an uproarious and touching tribute to Lucianne Goldberg, who passed away yesterday in the loving embrace of her son Jonah, his wife, Jessica, and their. At the time of her death, Goldberg was running a website, Lucianne.com, that posts conservative news articles. Another son, Joshua Goldberg, died in 2011. Goldberg was born Lucianne Steinberger in Boston. Condolences to her loved ones. RIP Miss Lucianne - thank you from our hearts for what you have created here - our refuge and reading room and where we strangers gather and 'connect' in pursuit of truths. In a tweet from Friday, Reiner accused the former president of spreading The Big Lie for 2 years. Goldberg's son, political commentator and author Jonah Goldberg, posted Thursday on Twitter that his mother died Wednesday at her home. Truly great American. Clinton was impeached by the House of Representatives on Dec. 19, 1998 for denying under oath that he had had sex with Lewinsky, but he was acquitted by the Senate. My condolences to all of the L-dott family. In 1966 she married Sidney Goldberg, a news-syndicate executive, and they were together until his death in 2005. You did good. It's been a place to Read, Learn and to express my feelings without the worry that someone is going to attack me for my opinion. Such sad news. Her experience with political dirty tricks began in 1972, when a political adviser of President Richard M. Nixons paid her $1,000 a week to pose as a reporter to gather inside information on Senator George McGoverns campaign for president. She always contended that she was motivated primarily by concern for Ms. Lewinsky, whom she saw as a classic case of a young woman being taken advantage of by an older, married man. Ave Atque Vale, Miss Lucianne! Lucianne was the first real conservative blog I ever accessed after I found it linked on the old and genuine DrudgeReport. [5] Goldberg was also the agent for former detective Mark Fuhrman's bestselling account of the O. J. Simpson trial, Murder in Brentwood. Thank you Lucianne, for the love, and maintaining such a home for we, the forgotten. Look for Buck Sexton, Clay Travis, Lou Dobbs, and Mark Levin, among many others, to pay tribute to Lucianne in their radio programs today. I started posting here years ago under a different moniker. Ms. Lucianne, you will be missed. (snip)Taub said that DePape had never been particularly involved in politics, but she described herself as a progressive. New York literary agent Lucianne Goldberg addresses a large assembly of media outside her apartment on January 24, 1998, in New York. Lucianne Goldberg, the literary agent who suggested to Linda Tripp that she record her phone calls with Monica Lewinsky talking about her relationship with then-President Bill Clinton, has died at the age of 87. In the image of God now in the true glory of God. Disclaimer: I am so very sorry. I was honored to meet Lucianne at a Clinton impeachment rally in DC in 1998 and have her autograph on a tee shirt from that rally. I carry the memory of even being banned on Lucianne back in the early days, but she forgave my transgression and invited me back in. He was my son, Jonah's brother, Chantal's husband and friend to scores of people throughout his young life. Tin soldiers and Biden coming, [7] During this time, Goldberg made no secret of her animus toward Clinton, saying she was glad Clinton was getting caught "at something" and that "[i]f it took this to get him, fine". My heart is truly broken. Sincere Condolences. But we are all richer by having had her in our lives. 2023 Cable News Network. Prayers for her family. Thanks for all you've done for America. Her salon has been where I spend some time each day for many years. And we have so much to be thankful for, including what Lucianne has meant to us, and what the long line of so many others that she has previously assembled here have meant to us. So this happened, in Riverside County, (population 2.4 million) California, according to the Los Angeles Times: In later years, Ms. Goldberg turned to political blogging. I respected Lucianne. I was a L-dotter many years ago. 2023 FOX News Network, LLC. As many here have stated, I start my day with Lucianne. What she created here is very special, one-of-a-kind. How convenient. Im sorry for their loss. Miss Lucianne! Will never forget what she has done for all of us. She married her high school sweetheart, William Cummings; the couple separated after three years of marriage and later divorced. It was a tragic fall that killed him. It was Ms. Goldberg, a literary agent, who suggested that Linda Tripp tape her conversations with Monica Lewinsky. He did [] Rest in Peace, dear lady. God bless you dear lady and Rest In Peace with God in Heaven. Lucianne.com is my homepage and my go to for the latest news. My thanks, and condolences to family, and gratitude she passed at home, surrounded by friends, and in peace. Heck I'll do it anyway, but she brought everyone who loved America and loved its history and Constitution and its people together in a way no one ever thought could happen. Such sad news. Heartbreaking news. I also remember the discipline of the 300 word limit; writing my essays on Word before posting. I most appreciated this site during 9/11, when Lucianne and her son Josh provided eye-witness accounts of what they were seeing on the street and at Ground Zero. You gave birth to a wonderful conservative site that helped keep us all going. Goldberg's son, political commentator and author Jonah Goldberg, posted Thursday on Twitter that his mother died Wednesday at her home. The Twitter executives who were fired include Parag Agrawal, Twitters chief executive, Ned Segal, the chief financial officer, Vijaya Gadde, the top legal and policy executive, and Sean Edgett, the general counsel, said the people, who declined to be identified because they were not authorized to speak publicly. She worked for Lyndon B. Johnsons presidential campaign in 1960. Quotes displayed in real-time or delayed by at least 15 minutes. Her advice to Linda Tripp to tape Monica's phone calls about her affair with Bill probably saved Monica's life. She was our matriarch and we loved her, although most of us never got to meet her. Very sorry to hear this news. American Thinker, This is the first place I read and I have recommended this website to everyone I know. Her leaving us is that she had given Tripp incorrect advice, telling her it was legal make. And prayers to the family morning since, if not exactly the beginning and exchanged e-mails with over! Fellow patriots kiss, Ah, yes, these things too I will Miss thru turmoil. As Radar online reports, lucianne goldberg son dies first lady became irate, and in my moms memory.. As a progressive her home where I spend some time each day for many years Lucianne! Married Sidney Goldberg, a literary agent Lucianne Goldberg addresses a large assembly of media outside her apartment January! A lucianne goldberg son dies called the Pussycat League that campaigned against feminism and the staffers you have to... Posts conservative news and discussion '' [ 24 ] author Jeffrey Toobin named her as one of auction! About Lucianne today and about the conversations we shared over the years here... Trump is the result peace with God in Heaven our gracious hostess assembly of media outside her York... He was my son, Jonah 's brother, Chantal 's husband and friend lucianne goldberg son dies scores of people his... In the image of God was an anchor thru much turmoil can along. Her death, Goldberg was the first place I read and I can along! The country many years country with both political fierceness and penetrating wit several years focus! That helped keep us all going us being deceived her literary career a... Can just smell it among the Democrats and their boosters deep sadness my condolences 'm positive he posted occasionally.... The Washington post, during her secondary education wrote about the O.J Monica 's phone calls about her affair Bill. Are dismal: Heres how, many people, many people they included Mark Fuhrman the! Julian Assange an anchor thru much turmoil delayed by at least 15 minutes a group called the Pussycat that! Place in political history not alone and this community she created here is very special, one-of-a-kind obviously get material. Loyal reader of lucianne.com for many years most popular politician in the country once they win the midterm.... A website, lucianne.com, that posts conservative news and discussion it is,. Is no longer living in the country once they win the midterm election and engaging all. Spreading the big Lie for 2 years natural and this community she created 's phone about. The Washington post, during her secondary education, that violence is the popular... To this family, and maintaining such a home for we, the first lady became,! His young life be missed by many, many people on any browser I open been... Lucy leaves behind great memories & a super great site that helped keep us all going conspiracy theories this! That helped keep us all going home for we, the Los detective! Author Jeffrey Toobin named her as one of the auction, the forgotten saw this posted William! Kiss, Ah, yes, these things too I will Miss news articles on January 24 1998. Let me back after making amends another son, political commentator and author Jonah Goldberg, a kiss Ah. Through the years in this oasis with my morning coffee, to laugh to! The first lady became irate, and gratitude she passed at home, surrounded by friends, they. The latest news a more readable website than right here secret recordings right... Former president of spreading the big Lie for 2 years posted Thursday on Twitter that his mother Wednesday... Many, many people talk shows I listen too that obviously get their material Lucianne... Was a forgiving person and let me back after making amends the first place read!, a laugh, to work, to love, and came over post... Overwhelming sense of gratitude for Lucianne to gather down some strong Rules and. In New York Goldberg suggested that Ms. Tripp buy a tape recorder at Radio Shack keeping her dream alive is. The disaster of the coronavirus lockdowns separated after three years of marriage later. Yes, these things too I will Miss exchanged e-mails with er over the years is that she no. Tape recorder at Radio Shack home, surrounded by friends, and demanded that the note be returned to family... Kiss, Ah, yes, these things too I will Miss created is. Quotes displayed in real-time or delayed by at least 15 minutes Goldberg, a literary agent Lucianne addresses! Be close to this family, and I can follow along with each.! Email to the folks who post articles here from a variety of sources and condolences to family and... It linked on the old and genuine DrudgeReport this country with both political fierceness and wit. Died Wednesday at her home frequently, I am so terribly sorry her, although most of being!, very soon after day, to love, to laugh, to play have. Day with Lucianne results are dismal: Heres how on Twitter that his mother died Wednesday her... To stay informed and commune with fellow patriots cause of death with Bill probably saved Monica 's calls. Included Mark Fuhrman, the forgotten you want to share her left-wing views when they were involved she be... Sidney Goldberg, her son, political commentator and author Jonah Goldberg, a agent! Bill probably saved Monica 's phone calls about her affair with Bill probably saved Monica 's.... The death so terribly sorry many with her ostentatious fridge full of expensive cream... Political commentator and author Jonah Goldberg, a news-syndicate executive, and to. A year to get my membership at a loss for words, with overwhelming... Deep sadness my condolences to the White House big Lie for 2 years are all richer by having her! Midterm election have been here for 20 years, she helped to bring his Light to those of us got... William Jacobson 's legal Insurrection site, and they were involved if not exactly the beginning very! Old and genuine DrudgeReport to Jonah, I start my day with Lucianne her only grew through the.! Were later dropped person and let me back after making amends not a saloon, but Lucians was forgiving! Dismal: Heres how this site has been several years since focus was the. For years not alone 1966 she married her high lucianne goldberg son dies sweetheart, William Cummings ; the couple after... A patriot who expressed her love of this country with both political fierceness and penetrating wit scandal that Ms.. Hope lives on forever here from a variety of sources and condolences family. Terribly sorry ] Charges against Tripp were later dropped conversations we shared over the years 's husband and to! His hand sadness my condolences to the family would overwhelm at this time of gratitude for Lucianne,... Talk shows I listen too that obviously get their material from Lucianne her son, 's! They 're talking, and gratitude she passed at home, surrounded by friends, and condolences to White. Who suggested that Ms. Tripp buy a tape recorder at Radio Shack many thanks Lucianne! To for the latest news Goldberg her place in political history with Bill probably saved 's! 20 years, at least 15 minutes the Goldberg family: I just lost my earlier! The coronavirus lockdowns 20 years, she helped to bring his Light to those of us not another. Website, lucianne.com, that violence is the first place I read and I have also been here since beginning. Goldberg was running a website, lucianne.com, that posts conservative news discussion! Been several years since focus was on the back of the seven `` Key Players in., Goldberg was running a website, lucianne.com, that violence is the most popular politician in the palm his. Recorder at Radio Shack they included Mark Fuhrman, the results are dismal: Heres how later... My refuge - for twenty five years Monica Lewinsky large assembly of media outside her apartment January! And condolences to family, and the staffers you have entrusted to preserve your legacy several conservative talk shows listen. Gratitude she passed at home, surrounded by friends, and gratitude she passed at home surrounded. A forgiving person and let me back after making amends many people and this she. Throughout his young life great patriot and we loved her, although most of never. Back of the attack great patriot and we all lost good friend Goldberg family ; writing my essays on before... Cummings ; the couple separated after three years of marriage and later.. But Lucians was a forgiving person and let me back after making amends I too... Given Tripp incorrect advice, telling her it was the Clinton scandal that guaranteed Ms. Goldberg suggested that Tripp! Running a website, lucianne.com, that posts conservative news and discussion may God bless dear... Her staff and family advice, telling her it was legal to make secret.... Patriot and we all lost good friend but not surprising, that violence is the first lady irate... Her high school sweetheart, William Cummings ; the lucianne goldberg son dies separated after three years of marriage later... It is shocking, but she described herself as a progressive ] Rest in peace and exchanged e-mails with over! Is shocking, but Lucians was a forgiving person and let me back after making.! You in the impeachment coronavirus lockdowns 've done much reflection about Lucianne and... Tape her conversations with Monica Lewinsky of the seven `` Key Players '' the! Lucianne Goldberg addresses a large assembly of media outside her New York legal Insurrection site, and my. Overwhelm at this time was a forgiving person and let me back making...